Skip to main content

Table 3 Blocked multi-response permutation procedure (MRBP) tests comparing 2008 variables to 2016 variables measured after the 2007 Egley Fire Complex in eastern, Oregon, USA. Boldface P-values denotes significance at the 95% confidence level, whereas boldface A-values are above 0.3 (strong within group agreement), and SE denotes the standard error within each group. NPV = non-photosynthetic (dead or dormant) vegetation; CWD = coarse woody debris

From: Short- and long-term effects of ponderosa pine fuel treatments intersected by the Egley Fire Complex, Oregon, USA

Variable description

P

A

2008 Mean (SE)

2016 Mean (SE)

Tree canopy cover (%)

<0.001

0.198

40.08 (1.56)

28.13 (2.61)

Live tree basal area (m2 ha–1)

<0.001

0.115

2.19 (0.34)

9.54 (1.14)

Dead tree basal area (m2 ha–1)

<0.001

0.063

1.34 (0.20)

5.57 (0.67)

Live tree density (stems ha–1)

<0.001

0.214

298.57 (42.10)

140.71 (16.82)

Dead tree density (stems ha–1)

<0.001

0.162

250.00 (36.33)

52.86 (6.32)

Live sapling density (stems ha–1)

0.036

0.012

104.29 (49.25)

40.00 (4.78)

Dead sapling density (stems ha–1)

<0.001

0.181

994.29 (176.2)

68.57 (8.20)

Live seedling density (stems ha–1)

0.001

0.027

571.43 (318.72)

236.43 (28.26)

Dead seedling density (stems ha–1)

0.081

0.008

600.00 (392.69)

7.14 (0.85)

Green vegetation cover (%)

<0.001

0.488

5.54 (0.68)

29.39 (3.51)

NPV cover (%)

0.003

0.052

49.74 (2.67)

58.41 (6.98)

Soil and rock cover (%)

<0.001

0.421

40.70 (2.66)

12.00 (1.19)

Char cover (%)

<0.001

0.675

59.69 (2.31)

7.34 (0.88)

Moss, lichen, and fungi cover (%)

<0.001

0.122

1.76 (0.78)

2.31 (0.28)

Shrub cover (%)

<0.001

0.106

0.94 (0.35)

6.53 (0.78)

Graminoid cover (%)

<0.001

0.356

4.47 (0.77)

14.15 (1.69)

Forb cover (%)

<0.001

0.117

7.14 (1.05)

10.92 (1.31)

Invasive cover (%)

<0.001

0.151

0.10 (0.09)

2.42 (0.29)

Total fuel loads (Mg ha–1)

<0.001

0.094

17.98 (2.39)

30.07 (3.59)

Fine fuel loads (Mg ha–1)

<0.001

0.110

7.21 (0.72)

11.00 (1.31)

CWD (Mg ha–1)

0.002

0.053

10.78 (3.19)

19.07 (2.28)

100-hour fuels (Mg ha–1)

0.008

0.034

1.69 (0.42)

1.31 (0.16)

10-hour fuels (Mg ha–1)

0.001

0.055

0.66 (0.12)

1.16 (0.14)

1-hour fuels (Mg ha–1)

<0.001

0.410

0.02 (0.00)

0.32 (0.04)

Litter (Mg ha–1)

<0.001

0.404

1.68 (0.22)

6.08 (0.73)

Duff (Mg ha–1)

0.052

0.019

3.16 (0.41)

2.14 (0.26)